Go to navigation Go to content

Gerry Oginski wins $1.5 Million Verdict in Podiatry Malpractice Case

Blog Category:
Gerry Oginski
Comments (0)
On Friday, July 23, 2010, a Westchester County jury in the Supreme Court of the State of New York determined that my client, Annemarie Flannery was entitled to be compensated $1.5 million as compensation for injuries caused by a podiatrist during bunion surgery. Her husband, David Flannery was entitled to be compensated $50,000 for his lost services claim.

The case involved a claim of a failure to properly perform foot surgery involving my client's bunion on her right foot. It was our claim that the podiatrist removed too much bone during the procedure, and improperly positioned the first metatarsal. As result, this changed the dynamic forces of her foot and forced her to bear most of her weight underneath the second and third metatarsals in her foot. We also claimed that the patient should have had her second and third metatarsals surgically shortened during her first bunion surgery. This would have prevented the problem from arising.

Instead, the patient developed pain, pressure and discomfort on the bottom of her foot following surgery. The podiatrist recommended corrective surgery to shorten the second and third metatarsals eight months after her first surgery. The patient became quite frustrated and no longer had confidence in the ability of the podiatrist. She then went to an orthopedic surgeon with a specialty in foot and ankle surgery in Manhattan. He performed surgery to shorten the second and third metatarsals, but because of the damage already taken place, his surgery was unable to fix the primary problem.

Since conservative treatment failed she's been offered additional surgery to correct the problem to shorten bones in her foot, or as an alternative, to undergo destructive surgery that will fuse bones in her foot. There are no guarantees that these surgeries will help improve her condition. At the present time, she has elected to deal with the pain and discomfort on a daily basis and may need to have one or both of these surgeries in the future.

After two weeks of a hard-fought trial in Westchester, and after listening to testimony from the podiatrist, the podiatrist's expert, our expert, the treating physician and the plaintiffs, the jury determined that this podiatrist departed from good and accepted podiatric and surgical care; that this departure was a substantial factor in causing my client injury, and that she was entitled to be compensated.

The jury awarded her $375,000 for past pain and suffering, for the last five years.
The jury awarded her $1,125,000 for future pain and suffering, representing future injury over the next 30 years.
The jury awarded her husband $50,000 for his loss of services claim.

This verdict represents a remarkable statement by a unanimous jury.

Category: Medical Malpractice

Gerry Oginski
NY Medical Malpractice & Personal Injury Trial Lawyer

5 Comments to "Gerry Oginski wins $1.5 Million Verdict in Podiatry Malpractice Case"

This changed the dynamic forces of her foot malpractice and forced her to tolerate most of her weight beneath the second and third metatarsals in her foot.
Posted by Cynthia Brandon on June 8, 2017 at 07:05 AM
Hi Gerry,

I have a similar situation to the story posted on your web of the bunionectomy. I am 45 years old and had a double bunionectomy with the 2nd metatarsals shortened. The Dr. shortened the left foot metatarsal too much, resulting in a bone protruding under 3rd metatarsal. He didnt acknowledge it much and advised me to get a good physical therapist and to see him to be fitted for orthotics. Long story short, I lost faith in him and sought consultations. I've had 4 Podiatrist inform me of the first surgery error. I am now going in for surgery #4 to correct surgery #1 and am hesitant .

I Strongly wish you practiced law in CA. I am having difficulty to find an attorney to take the case. Seems like they wan the BIG $$ by a amputation or wrongful death case. Do you have an extended practice in N. CA (bay area) or can you refer me to a Malpractice Attorney? Your help is greatly appreciated.
Posted by Julie Martinez on May 9, 2013 at 03:04 PM
I had bunion surgery that sounds like the same may have occurred, in the case above. I have swelling and my foot is deformed. I was an active person and now I can't do any of the activities as was my lifestyle.
Posted by Romana Van Houten on February 8, 2013 at 12:55 PM
Yes Gary, I did say Westchester.
Posted by Gerry on July 25, 2010 at 12:44 AM
Westchester? Did you say Westchester? I'll be getting a "Gerry" tatoo (guess no burial in a Jewish cemetary for me). Did you say Westchester?
Posted by gary rosenberg on July 25, 2010 at 12:33 AM

Post a comment

Post a Comment to "Gerry Oginski wins $1.5 Million Verdict in Podiatry Malpractice Case"

To reply to this message, enter your reply in the box labeled "Message", hit "Post Message."


Email:* (will not be published)


Notify me of follow-up comments via email.